Explain why one plausible reading is preferable to another.
An alternative must be plausible
Do not compare your reading with a deliberately silly version. For the stalled draft, one alternative is that more practice is avoidance and a direction must be chosen first. That preserves the same card actions while changing the relationship.
Find the deciding observation
Ask what would favour each version. A lack of usable material could support a practical trial. A pile of unused drafts with no chosen audience might support making the decision first. Neither fact is supplied by the cards; the learner needs to inspect the situation.
Keep the weaker version visible
Write why the preferred reading currently fits better and retain the alternative in the record. If the deciding information changes, you can revise for a stated reason. This is different from silently changing the meaning so it always seems correct.
Write your working response.
Write two plausible readings of a three-card spread. State one ordinary observation that would help you choose between them.
Open this lesson’s exercise →Check your understanding
What makes an alternative useful?
- It could reasonably fit the same actions, and a stated observation could distinguish it.
- It is obviously absurd.
- It guarantees the opposite outcome.
Reveal the teaching explanation
A. A real alternative tests your reasoning. It is not a straw version created to make your first answer look better.