The context you are allowed to use
You saved three striking appearances but did not record how many other readings you made.
Three proposed interpretations
- Describe the saved observations, build a complete record, and judge a later claim by a stated standard.
- Three appearances prove the recurrence could not be ordinary.
- The dramatic image supplies the external cause.
Before opening the teaching explanation, choose the most bounded claim and write what supports it. A preference for the conclusion is not a substitute for a reason.
Inspect the teaching explanation
Option A · Best bounded for this task
The interpretation separates the observation from a causal explanation and gives record-keeping a practical role.
Option B
The missing denominator prevents this frequency claim.
Option C
The picture does not establish a cause for its own appearance.
Trace every card’s contribution
- The Tower: the striking image under discussion, not proof of an event.
- Seven of Pentacles: reviewing the actual record of effort and results.
- Justice: a consistent standard for the conclusion.
Continue the exercise
Write the observation without using “always”, “impossible” or “message”. Then state what the next ten complete records should include.
This is an authored teaching case. The selected answer follows the stated method and context; it is not a machine verdict on your personal reading.